Brands

The History of Maybelline

From a Chicago mail-order cream named after the founder's sister to a drugstore giant inside L'Oréal.

A portrait of a man

Maybelline began with a brother noticing what his sister was doing. Tom Lyle Williams was a young man living in Chicago in the early 1900s. He watched his sister Maybel apply a mixture to her eyelashes to make them look darker, and he thought he could make a better version. The product he created was named by joining her name to the gelatine that went into it: Maybelline.

That origin story has been repeated in company histories for a century, and there is no reason to doubt its broad outline. What makes the brand important is not the family detail but the business model that followed. Maybelline showed that makeup could be sold cheaply, by mail and then in drugstores, to women who had no interest in the counters of a department store.

The first products

Williams launched a product called Lash-Brow-Ine in 1915. It was a cream designed to darken the lashes and brows, and it was sold by mail order. The name was awkward, but the idea was sound: a woman could order a cosmetic through the post and use it at home, without visiting a shop where someone might judge her.

The following years saw the introduction of a cake mascara, sold under the Maybelline name. The product came as a dark block that was moistened with a brush and applied to the lashes. It was inexpensive to make and to post, and it sold well. The company grew by adding related products: eyebrow pencils, eye shadows and, eventually, a full range of colour cosmetics.

The choice of the drugstore as a retail home was decisive. Department stores sold beauty counters with trained staff and high prices. Drugstores sold practical goods, and a customer could pick up a mascara along with toothpaste. Maybelline belonged to the second world, and the brand has kept that position ever since.

Growing up in America

Through the 1920s and 1930s, Maybelline expanded its range and its distribution. The company moved from mail order into shops, and the name became familiar to a generation of American women. The products were not fashionable in the way that a Parisian fragrance was fashionable, but they were useful and affordable.

The war years and the postwar period brought further growth. As more women entered the workforce, a quick, inexpensive makeup routine became more practical, and the brand’s products suited it. In the 1950s and 1960s, Maybelline added new formats and colours, and the packaging began to use the bright colours that would become characteristic.

Great Lash mascara, introduced in the early 1970s, became one of the brand’s defining products. It came in a distinctive pink-and-green tube and was sold at a price that almost anyone could afford. The formula was not remarkable, but it was reliable, and the product became a staple in drugstores for decades. Its longevity is unusual in a market driven by constant novelty.

Changes of ownership

The company remained family-controlled for several decades before being sold. In the 1960s, Maybelline was acquired by Plough Incorporated, a company that also owned a range of consumer health products. Later it passed to Schering-Plough, which combined pharmaceuticals with consumer brands.

In 1996, L’Oréal bought Maybelline. The French group already owned a large portfolio of beauty brands, but it lacked a strong presence in the American mass market. Maybelline gave it exactly that. The acquisition was one of the largest in the industry at the time and showed how seriously the big groups were taking the drugstore category.

Under L’Oréal, the brand has kept its identity as an affordable, accessible line. The parent company has provided research and manufacturing resources, which has improved the formulas, but the products are still sold at drugstore prices.

The message

Maybelline’s advertising has always been direct. The most famous slogan, “Maybe she’s born with it. Maybe it’s Maybelline,” appeared in the 1990s and summed up the brand’s promise: a small improvement that could be attributed to either nature or a tube of mascara. The line was memorable because it was self-aware, and it has remained associated with the brand ever since.

The campaigns have used well-known women, and the brand has often chosen people who seem approachable rather than distant. The messages have generally been about everyday beauty rather than glamour. A woman using Maybelline is not being transformed into someone else; she is being helped to look like a slightly better version of herself.

That approach has aged well. As the beauty industry has moved toward authenticity and away from airbrushed perfection, a brand built on ordinary usefulness has found itself in a favourable position.

The range today

Maybelline sells products across makeup, with a particular strength in mascara and foundation. Great Lash is still in production, alongside newer mascaras that use different brushes and formulas. The Fit Me foundation line, introduced in the 2010s, was built around a wide range of shades and a light texture, and it became one of the brand’s most successful products.

Superstay is another line that has lasted, built around long-wearing formulas for lipstick and foundation. The brand has also followed the trends of the market, adding products such as lip oils, skin tints and brow gels when those categories became popular. The range is large, and the company is quick to add a product that is selling well elsewhere.

The brand’s strength is its relationship with the drugstore shelf. Buyers who go in for one item often leave with several, and Maybelline’s low prices encourage trial. A customer can try a new shade without a significant commitment, which is a real advantage in a category where colour preferences change.

Manufacturing and scale

Making a mascara for a few dollars requires efficiency at a scale that a luxury brand never has to consider. The production lines run continuously, and the packaging is designed to be cheap and light. The formulas are straightforward, using well-understood ingredients that can be sourced in large quantities.

This does not mean the products are poor. A mass-market mascara from a large company benefits from the same research as a premium one, and the difference is often in the packaging and the claims rather than the basic formula. L’Oréal’s research network gives Maybelline access to developments in pigment and polymer chemistry that a smaller company could not afford.

The scale also brings pressure. A product that sells in the millions has to be consistent from one batch to the next, and a problem with a single ingredient becomes a major issue. Quality control at this level is a significant part of the business.

The brand’s place

Maybelline occupies a particular place in the beauty market. It is not sold as a luxury item, and the company does not pretend otherwise. The promise is usefulness at a low price, and the brand has kept that promise for more than a century.

That clarity is rare. Many brands drift upward in price and lose the customers who made them successful. Maybelline has stayed close to the drugstore, even as the parent company has bought and built brands at every price point.

The drugstore as a beauty destination

The drugstore became the natural home for Maybelline because of what it offered: low prices, open shelves and no pressure to buy. A woman could pick up a mascara, compare two shades and leave without speaking to anyone. That freedom was part of the appeal, especially for younger buyers who were not comfortable at a department store beauty counter.

The layout of the store shaped the products themselves. Packaging had to be bright enough to catch the eye from a shelf, and the price had to be visible. A luxury brand could rely on a salesperson; Maybelline had to sell itself. The company became skilled at designing packaging that communicated quickly, with clear names and colours that suggested the shade inside.

As drugstore chains grew in the second half of the twentieth century, they took more shelf space for cosmetics. Maybelline grew with them, and the relationship between brand and retailer became close. When the brand’s parent company wanted to enter a new market, the existing drugstore relationships made it easier to get the products into stores.

The legacy

The story of Maybelline begins with a brother who thought he could improve a mixture his sister was using on her lashes. What grew from that was a way of making cosmetics available to people who were not shopping in the elegant part of the store. The brand has never been the most fashionable or the most innovative, but it has been consistent, and consistency has made it one of the most recognisable and trusted names in beauty today.