Products

Mascara Types and Formulas

Waterproof, tubing, fibre and volumizing: what the labels mean and which formula suits your lashes.

A white vanity table with a mirror and cosmetics

Mascara is a small product with a surprising number of variations. Walk down a drugstore aisle and the labels promise length, volume, curl, definition and staying power, often on the same tube. Understanding the differences between the formulas makes it easier to choose one that suits your lashes and your day.

The main distinctions are straightforward once they are set out. The differences between waterproof and washable, between a classic film-forming formula and a tubing one, and between a brush built for length and one built for volume account for most of what is on the shelf.

The basic formula

Most mascaras work in the same way. A pigment is suspended in a base of waxes and oils, along with a solvent that evaporates after application. A wax such as beeswax or carnauba gives the product structure and helps it hold a curl. Oils keep it soft and help it glide. Pigment, usually carbon black or iron oxides, provides the colour.

When the mascara is applied, the solvent evaporates and leaves a film on the lash. The film adds thickness and darkness, and it holds the lash in a raised position. The formula’s balance of wax and oil determines how it behaves. More wax gives a firmer, longer-wearing product; more oil gives a softer, easier-to-remove one.

Waterproof versus washable

This is the most important distinction. A washable mascara uses water as the main solvent, which means it comes off with water and a gentle cleanser. It is comfortable to wear and easy to remove, but it can smudge if you cry or sweat.

A waterproof mascara replaces much of the water with volatile solvents and adds waxes that resist water. It survives rain, tears and humidity, which makes it useful for a long day, a wedding or a hot climate. The cost is that it is harder to remove and needs an oil-based cleanser or a dedicated remover. Held against the lashes for a few seconds, the remover dissolves the film without rubbing.

Some mascaras are labelled water-resistant rather than waterproof. They resist light moisture but will not survive a shower or heavy crying. The term is less regulated than it sounds, and the practical test is how much water the product can tolerate before smudging.

Tubing mascara

Tubing mascara uses a different approach. Instead of forming a continuous film, it uses polymers that wrap around each individual lash in a small tube. The tubes lengthen and define the lashes, and they come off with warm water and gentle pressure rather than with oil or solvent.

This makes tubing mascara a good choice for people whose eyes are sensitive to removers, and for anyone who finds waterproof mascara difficult to take off. It tends to resist smudging well, since the tubes are not easily broken by moisture, though it is not quite as durable as a strong waterproof formula in heavy rain.

The effect is usually lengthening and defining rather than dramatically volumizing. A person who wants very thick lashes may find a traditional formula more effective.

Volumizing and lengthening

These terms describe what the brush and the formula are designed to emphasise. A volumizing mascara has a thicker formula and often a dense brush with many bristles, which deposits more product onto each lash. It makes the lashes look thicker and darker. The trade-off is that too much product can lead to clumping.

A lengthening mascara is usually thinner and uses a brush with fewer, longer bristles, which combs the product through to the tips. It extends the appearance of the lashes and separates them. A curved brush can also lift the lashes, which creates the impression of length.

A defining mascara sits between the two and is designed to separate the lashes cleanly without adding much bulk. It is a good everyday choice, and it suits a person whose lashes are already full.

Fibre mascaras contain tiny fibres that attach to the lashes and add the appearance of length and thickness. They can be effective, but the fibres sometimes flake into the eye, and they are less common than they were.

The brush

The wand matters as much as the formula. A large, dense brush loads a lot of product and builds volume quickly, but it can be hard to control on short lashes. A slim brush reaches every lash and gives definition. A curved brush follows the shape of the eye and lifts the outer lashes.

Rubber and silicone brushes have firm, evenly spaced bristles that comb through the lashes and resist clumping. Traditional fibre brushes are softer and hold more product, which gives more volume. Hourglass-shaped brushes are narrow in the middle and wider at the ends, which is designed to reach short lashes at the inner and outer corners.

There is no single best brush. The right one depends on the lashes and on the effect wanted, and a person who tries a different brush shape may find that it changes the result more than a different formula would.

Shades

Black is the most common colour and gives the most definition. It suits most people, and it is the standard for a reason. Brown is softer and works well on fair colouring or for a natural daytime look. Dark brown gives much of the definition of black without the same hardness.

Coloured mascaras appear in every season and are usually a variation on a classic shade. Navy and deep plum are often used in place of black because they look slightly softer. Brighter colours are a deliberate style choice and work best with a simple eye look.

The shade should usually match the lashes rather than the eyebrows. A person with very dark lashes can wear black without thinking about it; someone with pale lashes may find brown more natural.

Choosing a formula

For daily wear, a washable defining or lengthening mascara is the easiest choice. It is comfortable, removable and unlikely to look too heavy. For a long day, an occasion or humid weather, waterproof is worth the extra effort of removal.

A person with sensitive eyes or who wears contact lenses may do better with a tubing or fragrance-free formula, and should avoid a product that stings. If the eyes water constantly, tubing mascara resists smudging without the need for a strong remover.

Short lashes usually benefit from a slim brush and a lengthening formula, while full lashes can carry a dense brush and a volumizing product. A person with straight lashes may find that a curling formula holds a lift better, though an eyelash curler used before application has a larger effect.

Common mistakes

Pumping the wand in and out of the tube is a common habit that introduces air and dries the product. The wand should be lifted out smoothly and wiped lightly at the neck of the tube.

Applying too many coats is another. Two thin coats give a cleaner result than one thick one, and more than two usually leads to clumps. Letting the first coat dry briefly before the second helps.

Using an old product is often overlooked. Mascara is usually recommended for replacement every three to six months, since bacteria can grow in the tube and the formula changes after opening. A mascara that has become thick or stringy should be discarded.

Sensitive eyes and reactions

A certain number of people react to mascara with redness, itching or swelling around the eyes. The cause may be a fragrance, a preservative or the remover rather than the mascara itself. A product labelled ophthalmologist-tested has been checked for use near the eyes, though it is not a guarantee that an individual will tolerate it.

A person prone to reactions can reduce the risk by choosing a fragrance-free formula, avoiding waterproof products that need strong removers and patch testing a new product on the jaw before using it on the lashes. If a mascara stings, the sensible response is to stop using it rather than to assume that all mascaras do the same.

Contact lens wearers often do well with a tubing or fragrance-free formula, since these are less likely to flake into the eye. Removing lenses before taking off eye makeup also reduces irritation.

The bottom line

Mascara formulas differ mainly in how they resist water, how they form a film on the lash and what the brush is designed to do. Washable is easy to remove, waterproof lasts longer, and tubing offers a middle ground for sensitive eyes. The brush shapes the result as much as the formula does. Choosing with those differences in mind makes the wide range on the shelf much easier to navigate.

A note on wear time

Most mascaras are designed to be worn for a day and removed at night. Leaving a product on longer than that increases the chance of irritation and makes removal harder, particularly with waterproof formulas. A person who wears mascara every day should treat removal as part of the routine rather than an optional extra.

The first coat is usually the one that matters. A careful application that separates the lashes looks better than several heavy coats, and it is easier to remove. A second coat, applied before the first has dried, is the usual cause of clumping.